In short
CARC 22 says the care may be covered by another payer under coordination of benefits. For children with two parental plans, the birthday rule usually decides which plan pays first. A denial often means the claim went to the wrong plan first, or the secondary plan did not receive the primary payer's explanation of benefits.
What this means
CARC 22: “This care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits.”Wording from the X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Code list.
CARC 22 reads: this care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits. It is saying it believes another plan should pay first, or that it needs to see what the other plan did.
It usually means one of three things. You billed the plan that is secondary as if it were primary. The payer's records show other coverage that your office did not know about. Or you billed the secondary plan without the primary payer's payment and adjustment information attached.
For adults, the plan that covers the person as an employee or subscriber is generally primary over a plan that covers the same person as a dependent. For a child covered under both parents' plans, many plans use the birthday rule.
The birthday rule compares the parents' birthdays by month and day only, not by year. The plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year is generally primary. Exceptions apply for separated or divorced parents and for plans that follow different rules, so confirm with the plans rather than relying on the rule alone.
Common dental triggers
| CDT code | Procedure (paraphrased) | Why it triggers this |
|---|---|---|
| D2740 | Porcelain or ceramic crown | High-dollar claims are where an unreported second plan matters most, and payers may review COB records more closely on large claims. |
| D1110 | Adult prophylaxis | Routine visit claims for patients with a spouse plan can be sent to the wrong plan first when the front desk assumes the order. |
| D0120 | Periodic oral evaluation | A child brought by either parent can generate claims under both plans, and the office may bill the plan the visiting parent carries. |
| D1206 | Topical application of fluoride varnish | Pediatric preventive claims are the usual place the birthday rule comes up, since a child may have two parental plans. |
CDT 2026 codes. CDT is copyrighted by the American Dental Association; procedure names here are short paraphrases, not official descriptors.
Can you appeal it?
Usually appealableCOB denials are usually fixable without a formal appeal. Once the correct primary is confirmed and the primary payer's EOB is attached, the secondary plan can process the claim. A formal appeal is needed only if the payer insists on a wrong primary order.
How to fix it: step by step
- Ask the patient for every dental card that covers them, including a spouse's or parent's plan, and record the subscriber's name, date of birth and relationship.
- Determine the order. For a child, compare each parent's birth month and day. For an adult covered as an employee on one plan and a dependent on another, start with the employee plan.
- Check the payer's eligibility portal or call provider services to confirm which plan it has on file as primary.
- If you billed the wrong plan first, ask that payer to reprocess or withdraw, and then bill the correct primary. If a plan paid in error as primary, it may later seek the money back, so tell the patient.
- After the primary plan pays, send the secondary claim with the primary EOB or the electronic payment and adjustment details. A secondary plan cannot calculate its portion without them.
- Find out which COB method the secondary plan uses, standard or non-duplication, and estimate the patient balance with that method before collecting anything.
Appeal or reconsideration checklist
- EOB or ERA line showing CARC 22 and any remark.
- Both plans' member cards and subscriber details with birth dates.
- Written or portal confirmation of which plan the payer considers primary.
- The primary payer's EOB or payment and adjustment details for the secondary claim.
- Any custody or divorce order provision the patient gave you, if parents are separated.
Write it off or bill the patient?
- Do not bill the patient for a CARC 22 denial. It is a routing problem, not a patient responsibility, until both plans have processed the claim.
- After both plans pay, the balance depends on the contracts and the COB method. Under standard COB the secondary calculates what it would have paid as primary and applies that amount to the balance the primary left unpaid, so the two plans together can pay up to the allowable expense. Under non-duplication the secondary pays only its normal benefit minus the primary payment, which is nothing if the primary paid at least as much.
- Check each in-network contract. Some limit what the patient can be charged when two plans share a claim, and state law and self-funded (ERISA) plans can differ.
Paper EOB versus ERA
On an 835/ERA this appears as CARC 22, often with a remark such as N479 (missing or incomplete COB explanation of benefits) or N36 (claim must meet the primary payer's processing requirements); paper EOBs may use the payer's own code. Look for phrases such as "other coverage on file," "not primary," or "send primary EOB."
Frequently asked questions
How does the birthday rule work?
For a child covered by both parents' plans, compare the two parents' birthdays by month and day, ignoring the year. The plan of the parent whose birthday comes first in the calendar year is generally primary. Different rules can apply for separated or divorced parents.
What if both parents share a birthday?
Under the NAIC model rule most states follow, the plan that has covered that parent longer is primary. Check the plans' own rules.
What is the difference between standard COB and non-duplication?
Under standard COB the secondary pays toward the balance left after the primary, up to what it would have paid on its own, so the two plans together can cover up to the allowable expense. Under non-duplication the secondary computes its normal benefit and subtracts the primary payment, so it pays nothing when the primary paid as much or more. The ADA notes non-duplication is typically used in self-funded plans.
Can I submit to both plans at the same time?
Secondary plans usually will not process a claim until the primary has paid, so billing both at once tends to produce a CARC 22 denial or a delay.
Related guides
Sources
- X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (code list and wording)
- X12 Remittance Advice Remark Codes (code list and wording)
- ADA: Current Dental Terminology (CDT) overview
- NAIC Model Regulation MO-120 coordination of benefits (state adoption text)
- ADA: Coordination of benefits guide
- Connecticut Office of the Healthcare Advocate: the birthday rule explained
Published by AI DentPro Editorial. Last reviewed November 13, 2026.