In short
CARC 97 tells you the payer considers a service already included in the payment for another procedure it has processed, so it pays nothing separately. In dental offices this most often hits buildups billed with crowns, evaluations billed together, palliative care billed with real treatment, and maintenance billed on the same day as a cleaning.
What this means
CARC 97: “The benefit for this service is included in the payment/allowance for another service/procedure that has already been adjudicated.”Wording from the X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Code list.
CARC 97 means the payer matched your line against another line on the same claim or a recent claim and decided the benefit is already built into that other payment. The payer is saying the two services should not be paid separately.
Bundling logic is set by each payer's edits, not by one national rule, so a pair that pays at one carrier can adjust at another. The CDT code descriptors sometimes state that a code is not reported with a particular other code, and that is the strongest ground in a dispute.
The adjustment is usually reported under group code CO, although X12 does not restrict which group code a payer uses with CARC 97. Unless the payer's contract says otherwise, that amount is a write-off and not a patient balance.
Remittances may pair CARC 97 with a remark code such as M15 (separately billed services have been bundled as components of the same procedure) or N19 (procedure code incidental to primary procedure).
Common dental triggers
| CDT code | Procedure (paraphrased) | Why it triggers this |
|---|---|---|
| D2950 | Core buildup, including pins when needed | Billed with a crown on the same tooth. Some payers pay it only when the record shows substantial missing tooth structure, and others fold it into the crown allowance. |
| D0140 | Limited oral evaluation, problem focused | Billed on the same date as a comprehensive or periodic evaluation. The payer treats one evaluation as the diagnostic service for the day. |
| D0150 | Comprehensive oral evaluation | Paired with D0140 or another evaluation on the same visit, so one of the two lines is adjusted as included. |
| D9110 | Palliative treatment of dental pain, per visit | Billed on a day when definitive treatment was also done. Many payers treat the pain relief as part of the definitive treatment when both are done on the same tooth at the same visit. |
| D1110 | Adult prophylaxis | Billed on the same date as periodontal maintenance. Periodontal maintenance already includes plaque and calculus removal and polishing, so the two are not reported for the same visit and the payer pays one. |
| D4910 | Periodontal maintenance | The other half of the D1110 pairing. Report the one service that matches the patient's periodontal status; if both are sent, payer edits decide which line is adjusted. |
CDT 2026 codes. CDT is copyrighted by the American Dental Association; procedure names here are short paraphrases, not official descriptors.
Can you appeal it?
Sometimes appealableStrong when the CDT descriptor or your chart shows the services were genuinely separate, such as two different teeth or two distinct clinical reasons. Weak when the payer's contract lists the pair as bundled; there the fix is changing how future claims are coded or documented, not appealing.
How to fix it: step by step
- Identify the pair. The remark code and the other lines on the claim show which service the payer folded into which.
- For D2950, check the chart note and radiograph: does the record show how much tooth structure was missing and why the buildup was needed for retention? If the note only says "buildup done," add detail before resubmitting.
- For two evaluations on one date, confirm which one reflects what actually happened. A true emergency exam added to a scheduled recall may be a legitimate separate service; a second routine exam is not. Bill only the one the visit supports.
- For D9110 with definitive treatment, ask whether the palliative step was separate from the final procedure. If the patient was treated for pain and returned another day for the restoration, the dates of service should show that.
- For D1110 and D4910 on the same date, correct the claim to the single service the chart supports. Periodontal maintenance includes the prophylaxis components, so the two should not both be reported for one visit.
- If the service was separate, send a corrected claim or reconsideration with the chart note, the relevant radiograph, and a one-sentence explanation of why the services were distinct.
Appeal or reconsideration checklist
- EOB or ERA line with CARC 97 and any remark code.
- Chart note for each disputed service with date, tooth number, and clinical reason.
- Radiograph or intraoral photo supporting the separate service.
- The CDT descriptor language you are relying on, cited by code only.
Write it off or bill the patient?
- If the payer's bundling is correct under your contract, write off the CARC 97 amount.
- Do not bill the patient for a bundled service on an in-network claim unless your contract allows it for that situation. State non-covered-services laws and self-funded (ERISA) plans vary.
- Out of network, bundled amounts may still be limited by the plan. Treat the patient balance as the plan's call, not yours, until the payer confirms in writing.
Paper EOB versus ERA
On an 835/ERA this appears as CARC 97; paper EOBs may use the payer's own code. Look for phrases like "included in another procedure," "incidental," or "allowance for this service is included in" next to the line.
Frequently asked questions
Can I bill a buildup with a crown?
Often yes, but payers differ on the documentation they require. Many look for evidence that a meaningful amount of tooth structure was missing.
Why did only one of my two evaluations pay?
Many payers allow a single evaluation per visit. If the second one was a different clinical situation, document that and ask for reconsideration; otherwise bill only the evaluation the visit supports.
How do I prevent repeat CARC 97 denials?
Keep a short list of pairs each major payer bundles, built from your own remittances over the past year, and check new claims against it before sending.
Related guides
Sources
- X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (code list and wording)
- X12 Remittance Advice Remark Codes (code list and wording)
- ADA: Current Dental Terminology (CDT) overview
- Example dental plan certificate (State of Michigan / Delta Dental)
Published by AI DentPro Editorial. Last reviewed November 13, 2026.